10 Reasons Not to Renounce Your U.S. Citizenship Right Now

US passport on map of Europe

10 Reasons Not to Renounce Your U.S. Citizenship Right Now


In a world that feels increasingly complex and restrictive with filings, the value of a U.S. passport might seem like too much of a burden to keep, especially for those who’ve made their lives in lands far from American shores. Who wouldn’t want to give up the heavy burden of annual filings? According to reports from the U.S. government, the number of people giving up their citizenship has increased year after year, with many trying to escape the far reach of the U.S. government.

While it may seem tempting for many to renounce their citizenship, here are ten reasons why it is worth reconsidering before making the irrevocable choice.


1. The Holocaust Mentality


In an era where geopolitical tensions and economic instability seem to be on the rise, holding onto your U.S. citizenship offers a form of insurance that is hard to quantify but invaluable in times of need. The concept of a “safety net” isn’t just metaphorical; for many, it’s a literal lifeline that provides peace of mind amidst global uncertainty. This sentiment has been echoed throughout history and what I call the Holocaust Mentality. People want a second place they can run to if necessary. Almost no one with parents who lived through the holocaust and went through that horrible experience would dare give up their U.S. citizenship.

The October 7th terrorist attack and the Russia-Ukraine war, among other global crises, have only reinforced the value of this insurance policy. They give people a view of an ugly nightmare of how bad things could get and how critical a “Plan B” is.

Therefore, holding onto U.S. citizenship isn’t merely about the benefits it provides in stable times but about the security and options it offers when stability is threatened. It’s a reminder that in a world where change is the only constant, the value of a backup plan cannot be overstated.


2. Missing Out on Actual Cash Payments: Refunds, Credits, and Stimulus Benefits


Amidst the complexities of global taxation, U.S. citizenship emerges as a surprisingly beneficial asset, especially for those residing in high-tax countries. The United States’ unique tax system, which allows for offsetting taxes paid in other countries, often results in significant refunds and credits for its citizens living abroad. These financial advantages can accumulate substantially, making a compelling case for retaining U.S. citizenship.

For American families living overseas, the Child Tax Credit and other refundable credits can result in yearly refunds that bolster financial security and savings. During the COVID-19 pandemic, U.S. citizens, regardless of their residence, were eligible for thousands of dollars in stimulus checks. Renouncing citizenship means closing the door on these and future benefits, potentially costing individuals and families tens of thousands of dollars over a lifetime.

In a world where financial security is increasingly sought after, the economic advantages provided by U.S. citizenship—from tax refunds to educational credits and stimulus benefits—offer a compelling argument for those considering the renunciation of their citizenship to reconsider the financial implications of such a decision. The fiscal benefits, often overlooked in the discourse on citizenship, warrant a closer examination for anyone contemplating this irreversible step.


3. University Opportunities and Credits


The value of U.S. citizenship extends into the realm of education, where it opens doors to a myriad of opportunities and financial aids not readily available to non-citizens. The advantages for students and families considering higher education are twofold: access to a wide array of prestigious institutions and eligibility for valuable educational credits. For instance, the American Opportunity Tax Credit offers a significant rebate for educational expenses during the first four years of higher education, encompassing a range of institutions, including many abroad, that the U.S. Department of Education recognizes.

Moreover, U.S. citizenship simplifies the admission process into U.S. universities, renowned worldwide for their quality of education, diversity, and research and professional development opportunities. The complexities of student visas, international student quotas, and additional bureaucratic hurdles are non-issues for U.S. citizens, allowing for a smoother transition into university life and beyond.

In an age where education is increasingly seen as a cornerstone of personal and professional success, the benefits of U.S. citizenship in facilitating access to quality education and financial support are undeniable. That is, at least, if you are willing to pay the increasingly crazy amount of U.S. tuition and don’t believe that everything can be learned online these days.


4. Travel Convenience and Opportunities


Traveling with a U.S. passport is easier, offering visa-free or visa-on-arrival access to a vast number of countries. This ease of travel should not be dismissed easily. For many, traveling extensively without the bureaucratic entanglements of visa applications is a significant advantage, fostering greater understanding and connectivity in an increasingly globalized world.

Beyond the practical benefits, travel as a U.S. citizen can be enriching, allowing individuals to experience diverse cultures, forge international relationships, and gain invaluable perspectives in both personal and professional contexts.

That being said, many European passports may allow for greater travel opportunities without some of the burdens that a U.S. passport carries.

The convenience of travel afforded by U.S. citizenship is more than a luxury; it facilitates the global mobility that defines our contemporary existence. In a time when global networks and international collaborations are ever more important, the ability to move freely across borders is an asset that underscores the value of retaining U.S. citizenship.


5. Work Opportunities in the Hi-tech Arena


Many non-U.S. people are relocating to the U.S. for work and getting visas. The allure of the United States as a hub for innovation and professional growth cannot be overstated. Holding a U.S. passport provides unparalleled access to Silicon Valley’s vibrant job markets, New York’s bustling business districts, and emerging tech scenes in cities like Austin and Seattle. U.S. citizenship simplifies the often complex and restrictive process of securing work visas or employment authorizations for those in high-tech, creative industries, or multinational corporations.

The ability to work in the U.S. without the need for employer sponsorship opens up a broad spectrum of career opportunities and offers a level of job mobility and security that is particularly valuable in today’s fast-paced and ever-changing professional landscapes. Whether taking up a short-term project, pursuing long-term employment, or even venturing into entrepreneurial endeavors, U.S. citizenship facilitates these career moves with far less bureaucratic friction than non-citizens.


6. Maintaining Family Connections and Heritage


One of the most poignant reasons to retain U.S. citizenship lies in the bonds of family and heritage. For many, the U.S. is not just a place of birth or citizenship; it’s home to generations of memories, traditions, and relationships. The ease with which U.S. citizens can visit family in the States, attend important milestones, or simply reconnect with their roots is invaluable. This ease extends to the spontaneous moments that define family life—last-minute weddings, reunions, or even the unfortunate instances of illness or loss—where the immediacy of presence is irreplaceable.


7. U.S. Social Security Benefits


Navigating the complexities of retirement planning is daunting for many, yet U.S. citizens abroad have a unique advantage in the form of potential Social Security benefits. These benefits, accrued through years of work and contribution to the system, form a cornerstone of financial security in one’s later years. Renouncing U.S. citizenship prematurely could mean forfeiting this critical financial safety net for those who have not yet secured the requisite 40 quarters of contributions.

Let’s make sure to put one misconception to rest. If you already qualify to receive social security benefits, then giving up your citizenship won’t block you from being able to claim them when you reach retirement age. Many are nervous they will lose the amounts they have paid in already. That won’t happen, and you can still request the monthly payments. However, if you haven’t yet paid in fully, you may want to do that before renouncing citizenship.


8. Tax Implications on Inheritance and Investments


Part of the uncertainty now is that we don’t yet know who will be the next president of the U.S. and how they will change U.S. inheritance and gift tax rules. However, we do know that currently, if you are not a U.S. person and you hold more than $60,000 value of U.S. stocks and/or U.S. real estate, you will be subject to an estate tax as high as 40%. That’s right, not 4%, 40%! That means if you hold stocks of a U.S. tech giant and pass away with stocks valued at $200,000, your loved ones left behind will likely need to pay a $56,000 tax bill.

While U.S. citizens are also subject to an inheritance or estate tax, the threshold is currently nearly $13.6M of worldwide assets. If you own less than $13.6M in net worth, you can still hold that $200,000 of U.S. stocks, and your loved ones will have a U.S. tax of $0 when you pass away. That’s a much better outcome, especially considering the recent real estate and stock market increases.


9. Professional Licenses and Credentials


For professionals who have dedicated years to earning licenses and accreditations, the thought of jeopardizing these credentials is a serious concern. Many professional licenses, particularly those issued by state boards in fields such as medicine, law, and engineering, are intricately linked to one’s citizenship status. While not all licenses are invalidated by renouncing U.S. citizenship, the potential risks and complications warrant a thorough evaluation.

The implications extend beyond mere professional practice; they touch on identity, achievement, and the culmination of years of hard work. Before making any decisions, a detailed review of how citizenship status affects professional standing is essential, underscoring the multifaceted nature of the renunciation decision.


10. The Exit Tax


Perhaps one of the most immediate and tangible considerations for those contemplating renouncing U.S. citizenship is the exit tax. This tax acts as a settling of accounts, calculating what might have been owed to the IRS had one remained a citizen. The rules governing the exit tax are complex. They can ensnare those unprepared for its reach, potentially levying taxes on worldwide assets as if they were sold the day before renunciation. However, with careful planning and professional guidance, mitigating or even avoiding the exit tax is possible, though this often requires strategic financial maneuvers well before renunciation.

The exit tax underscores the importance of viewing citizenship not just through a lens of national identity or emotional ties but as a significant financial and legal status with profound implications.


Not Going It Alone


If you find yourself at a crossroads, contemplating the weighty decision of whether to renounce your U.S. citizenship, know that you do not have to navigate this path alone. The intricacies of legal, financial, and tax implications call for expert guidance to illuminate the way forward. Consulting with professionals specializing in expatriate taxation, immigration law, and financial planning can provide the clarity and insight needed to make an informed decision.

Should you be contemplating this significant life choice, we encourage you to reach out for support and guidance. Our team of experts is here to assist you in evaluating your unique situation, exploring all available options, and ultimately making a decision that aligns with your personal and financial goals. Remember, the decision to renounce U.S. citizenship is irreversible, and the stakes are high. Contact us for assistance.

To read more about the flip side of this issue, check out our other blog here.


Did you enjoy this post? Sign up to receive our latest News & Insights!

Field are marked with * are required.

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: . You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact